(news article link via Beth of Yeah, Right, Whatever)
81-year-old Myron Manders was listed by the Social Security Administration as being dead.
His showing up the SSA office to correct the error was insufficient to prove to them otherwise.
A transcript of the discussion – as captured by SSA security tapes of the incident – follows in the extended entry (with apologies to Monty Python)…
MYRON MANDERS: [Knock]
SOCIAL SECURITY: Come in.
MYRON MANDERS: Ah, Is this the right room to prove that I’m alive?
SOCIAL SECURITY: I told you once.
MYRON MANDERS: No you haven’t
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I have.
MYRON MANDERS: When?
SOCIAL SECURITY: Just now.
MYRON MANDERS: No you didn’t.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I did.
MYRON MANDERS: You didn’t
SOCIAL SECURITY: I did!
MYRON MANDERS: You didn’t!
SOCIAL SECURITY: I’m telling you I did!
MYRON MANDERS: You did not!!
SOCIAL SECURITY: Oh, I’m sorry, just one moment. Are you actually alive, or just on paper?
MYRON MANDERS: Oh, I’m actually alive.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Ah, thank you. Anyway, I did.
MYRON MANDERS: You most certainly did not.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Look, let’s get this thing clear; I quite definitely told you.
MYRON MANDERS: No you did not.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I did.
MYRON MANDERS: No you didn’t.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I did.
MYRON MANDERS: No you didn’t.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I did.
MYRON MANDERS: No you didn’t.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes I did.
MYRON MANDERS: You didn’t.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Did.
MYRON MANDERS: Oh look, this isn’t helping me prove I’m alive.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes it is.
MYRON MANDERS: No it isn’t. It’s just bureaucratic idiocy.
SOCIAL SECURITY: No it isn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: It is!
SOCIAL SECURITY: It is not.
MYRON MANDERS: Look, you just acted like a bureaucratic idiot.
SOCIAL SECURITY: I did not.
MYRON MANDERS: Oh you did!!
SOCIAL SECURITY: No, no, no.
MYRON MANDERS: You did just then.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Nonsense!
MYRON MANDERS: Oh, this is futile!
SOCIAL SECURITY: No it isn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: I came here to prove that I’m alive.
SOCIAL SECURITY: No you didn’t; no, you came here to update the form that says you’re deceased. Which you can’t do because you’re not alive.
MYRON MANDERS: Whether I’m alive or not isn’t dependant on what’s written on some silly government form.
SOCIAL SECURITY: It can be.
MYRON MANDERS: No it can’t. Being alive is a medical status of continual cardiac, respiratory, and cerebral functionality.
SOCIAL SECURITY: No it isn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: Yes it is! It’s not a bloody checkmark on a form!
SOCIAL SECURITY: Look, dead people are indicated on this form by the word “deceased”, aren’t they?
MYRON MANDERS: Yes, but a scribble on a piece of paper is NOT the same thing as being a lifeless corpse bereft of the aninimating spirit!
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes it is!
MYRON MANDERS: No it isn’t!
SOCIAL SECURITY: Yes it is!
MYRON MANDERS: Life is an ongoing physical process. What’s on the form is merely a subsidiary function of whether I am currently engaged in that process. My continued existence is the controlling factor for what’s on that form.
[short pause]
SOCIAL SECURITY: No it isn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: It is.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Not at all.
MYRON MANDERS: Now look.
SOCIAL SECURITY: [Rings bell] Good Morning.
MYRON MANDERS: What?
SOCIAL SECURITY: That’s it. Good morning.
MYRON MANDERS: I was just getting my point across.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Sorry, the form still says you’re dead.
MYRON MANDERS: I was never dead!
SOCIAL SECURITY: I’m afraid you are.
MYRON MANDERS: I’m not.
[Pause]
SOCIAL SECURITY: I’m sorry, but I’m not allowed to talk to dead people.
MYRON MANDERS: What?!
SOCIAL SECURITY: If you want me change the form to indicate that you’re not dead, you’ll have to be alive to do it.
MYRON MANDERS: Yes, but I am alive! Oh come on!
SOCIAL SECURITY: [Hums]
MYRON MANDERS: Look, this is ridiculous.
SOCIAL SECURITY: I’m sorry, but I’m not allowed to talk to you unless you’re alive… and you pay the “updating the paperwork” fee…
MYRON MANDERS: Oh, all right.
[pays money]
SOCIAL SECURITY: Thank you.
[short pause]
MYRON MANDERS: Well?
SOCIAL SECURITY: Well what?
MYRON MANDERS: You can mark me down as being alive now.
SOCIAL SECURITY: I told you, I’m not allowed to talk to you unless you’re not dead and you pay the fee.
MYRON MANDERS: I just paid!
SOCIAL SECURITY: No you didn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: I DID!
SOCIAL SECURITY: No you didn’t.
MYRON MANDERS: Look, I’m alive and I paid the fee.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Well, you couldn’t have paid, because your file still lists you as being dead.
MYRON MANDERS: Aha! If I’m dead, why are you talking to me? I Got you!
SOCIAL SECURITY: No you haven’t.
MYRON MANDERS: Yes I have. If you’re talking to me, I must be alive and I must have paid.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Not necessarily. I could have stolen this money off your corpse.
MYRON MANDERS: Oh I’ve had enough of this.
SOCIAL SECURITY: No you haven’t.
MYRON MANDERS: Oh Shut up!
I love Monty Python, and now, by extension, I love IMAO.
Gets on knees, fumbles diamond ring…
Ah, to heck with it.
That was good. I could almost hear Cleese’s voice saying your words.
Has anyone ever seen the movie “Brazil”? If you like parodies of bureaucracy, you’ll enjoy this one.
I expected something more like the Dead Parrot Sketch…
“Nobody expects the… Oops, wrong cue…”
“IMAO has two weapons. They are humor, satire, and para…Three! IMAO has three weapons. Humor, satire, paraody and spacemonkey..Four! There are…”
That was fantastic! Cleese and Palin, duking it out on IMAO. Fantastic Tribute! Many Kudos to you, Harvey!
Heh, I’m a weapon.
Actually, I was visualizing John Cleese as Myron Manders and Eric Idle as the Social Security bureaucrat…
Great! I heard the accents and everything while I read it!! I love Monty Python!
Sorry, this is abuse. Arguements are just down the hall.
Seth, Palin was the man who came for the argument.
//Seth, Palin was the man who came for the argument.//
DE: no he wasn’t.
Shim, he is in the Flying Circus episode in which this appears.
I’ve the Audio file at home and I’ve watched the Flying Circus Episode tons of times. It’s Palin and Cleese. The Abuse fellow is Chapman.
Screen cap proving me right is here.